The Chocolate Peppermint Stick tastes exactly like you’d expect from the name. The main flavor is strongly peppermint, but the creme de cacao is powerful, too. If you’ve ever had one of those peppermint sticks that has a chocolate ribbon woven through it instead of the usual red fruity ones, that’s about what this drink tastes like.
This drink should be regarded as a double, and therefore might not be your best choice for a party (particularly if people will be driving themselves home). It’s wonderful to sip along on a night in. It’s also sweet enough to substitute for dessert – like a chocolate after dinner mint with a kick. Except, a lot of chocolate-mint candies use dark chocolate, and the Chocolate Peppermint Stick has more of a milk chocolate flavor.
Around Christmas time, when you can get candy canes, I garnish these by just dropping a cane in. But during the rest of the year, you can buy starlight mints, crush them up, and rim your glass with crushed hard peppermint candy. And if rimming is more trouble than you want to go to, just sprinkle the crushed peppermint over the top.
And of course, you can also do a chocolate garnish if you prefer. Drizzle chocolate syrup down the insides of the glass, or rim it with cocoa powder.
You can also make this one with dark creme de cacao, and the color of the drink will be a light, creamy brown. It’ll taste pretty similar either way, so it’s just a matter of whether you want a pure white cocktail or light brown. Some people prefer that a chocolate cocktail have some brown coloration.